The Colour Of Memory

May 4, 2008

Twenty More

Filed under: Books, Music — Tags: , — rottenhat @ 11:13 am

April 25, 2008

We Are All Visceral Realists Now

Filed under: Books — Tags: , — rottenhat @ 4:41 pm

Roberto BolanoLanguage still creates islands that the immediacy of modern communications has not erased. It remains possible for a writer to create a substantial oeuvre encompassing poetry, short stories and novels, to win a number of awards and be acclaimed as the most important figure of his generation by fellow writers, to die an early death, and be largely unknown to the English-speaking public. But for a review in the LRB I would probably still be unaware of the Chilean writer, Roberto Bolano, and it took me six months to actually get around to ordering the Savage Detectives. It will be another seven months before Farrar, Straus and Giroux publish his other novel 2666 in translation. Now that I know his name, I start to see it in other places…another book, by Cesar Aira, with a glowing encomium from Bolano prominent on the cover. Still, there’s a faint air of unreality about it, as though he were a creation of Borges, somehow retroactively himself backwards into history.

The Savage Detectives is real enough, a big, sprawling, unpredictable book that took me three weeks to finish. It’s written in three parts - excerpts from the diaries of Juan Garcia Madero bookend the four hundred page middle section, an oral history of the lives of the visceral realist poets Arturo Belano and Ulises Lima told in a dazzling multiplicity of competing voices. Madero is callow, a young poet inspired by his induction into the ranks of the visceral realists, and his diaries reflect this - the writing is sometimes flat, sometimes jarring, but sets the scene for the flight of all three from Mexico City with a vengeful pimp in pursuit which ends the first section. Then the babel breaks loose - the glorious cavalcade of thirty or forty contending voices describing their encounters with Belano and Lima. What is interesting is that these characters, from the garrulous old poet Amadeo Salvatierra to the deranged architect Quim Font, become far more vivid than the men they are talking about. The stories contradict each other and as the different views overlay each other, the image becomes blurred. The history moves forward more or less chronologically, with increasingly large gaps in time separating the accounts, until finally there are no further memories of either Belano or Lima. The visceral realist leaders vanish from the pages of history, and the academic who is their self-appointed historian denies that there ever was a poet named Juan Garcia Madero.

Madero’s diaries describe the visceral realists as an incestuous tangle of poets, convinced of the revolutionary importance of their art, even as the politics of the group drive them towards scission. Yet as the book proceeds, Belano and Lima increasingly appear hollowed out: bereft of the conviction that fuelled their poetic fervour, they become melancholy, haunted figures, drifting the globe. When Belano finally disappears into the jungle in Liberia, facing almost certain death, he is as the walking dead, glad to meet his doom. The final section, Madero’s diary of their journey into the desert, gives one explanation of the riddle that nags throughout the book, the event that wreaks these devastating changes. But it can’t be the full explanation, just one possible reason, something that can be inferred from the words of one witness, who can have no presentiment of what is to come. I didn’t build up much momentum reading the Savage Detectives: days would pass before I would pick it up again, but it rarely seemed to matter. There was always more there than can be understood in a single reading.

April 10, 2008

Love & Napalm

Filed under: Books — Tags: — rottenhat @ 1:00 pm

The final chapter of JG Ballard’s recent memoir reveals that he has terminal cancer. I think this was already public knowledge, and I had heard that this was likely to be his last book, but I hadn’t previously known the details of his illness. I will miss him greatly. No writer has so incisively anatomised post-war western culture: the fascination of technology, the eroticisation of violence and consumerism, the cult of celebrity.  If his aim was not as unerring in his later work, it remained proof that fiction was capable of more revealing insights into the human condition than anything offered by the literary herd that clogs the review pages and the 3 for 2 tables.

Miracles Of Life is in some respects a peculiar memoir, losing steam rapidly once Ballard’s career as a writer begins, and tailing off with a few fragmentary episodes from the last decades of his life, many of them already described in similar terms in past interviews. It could be that his failing health began to take more of a toll in the later stages of writing the book. More likely he recognised that the life of a professional writer, more particularly one who is also bringing up three children as a single parent, tends to the repetitive and the mundane. It’s clear that his childhood in Shanghai and experience of internment during the Second World War have been the dominant influnces on his writing. For a long time I was leery of reading Empire Of The Sun, assuming that as a Booker nominee it had to be a distinctly more conventional novel than Crash or High Rise. Now I would consider it the vital counterweight to those books, precisely delineating the buried incidents that gave rise to the key motifs and themes in Ballard’s books. This is where the visions of drained swimming pools and abandoned aircraft on runways originate, this is where he develops his convictions about the atavistic urges that motivate humans, and the precariousness of the veneer of civilisation that disguises them.

The same source material reappears in the memoir but, freed from the strictures of the novel, it has a clarity that seems almost distilled. This is some of Ballard’s best writing, as lucid and compact as ever, and every sentence is telling. It also has a personal and emotive quality that is often missing from his fiction. His novels pay little attention to character, the same types reappearing under similar names in book after book, with only a few blank and abstracted references to their feelings. It’s fascinating then to see him describing his relationship with his family, his regret at the distance that existed between him and his parents, and the obvious love and pride he has for his children and his partners.

I have come to think that human rationality is in many ways a chimaera, that the reasons we give for our actions are frequently post-hoc rationalisations for what we have done, rather than the motivation for those actions. We assume too great a gulf between ourselves and the rest of the animal world - even if (and I mean if) human intelligence is of another order than the rest of the mammals, we can’t have evolved so far from them as to be entirely free of instinctive behaviour, to be free of primitive impulses. Yet we like to think that we have freed ourselves of the drives that preserved our place in the process of natural selection because in the short period of our written history reason and technology have proven such effective tools. Ballard’s conviction that the atrocities he witnessed during the war are evidence that in large part humans have a taste for violence rings true. Civilisation survives because we can be trained like any other animal. We can imbue ourselves with responses that go against the grain, but any theory of human society that does not take into account the non-rational side of our being is doomed to failure.

Our experience of consciousness as being continuous is another rationalisation, the mind papering over the cracks and discontinuities of daily experience in the attempt to shoehorn it all into an explicable schema. Perhaps this is what is so often unsatisfying about conventional literary fiction - these microscopically parsed descriptions of personality, experience, psychology are descriptions of just such a rationalisation. In their focus on conscious experience they fail to put their finger on the unconscious urges that drive us, nor can they accommodate the jagged, allusive, irrational complexity of our immediate response to raw experience. The images of the surrealists have been co-opted by commerce and neutralised through familiarity but their attempt to drop stones into the well of the unconscious and see what rises to the surface must continue to be combed for insights. Likewise, the uncanny power of Francis Bacon’s best work must not be simply boxed-off, remarked upon yet essentially ignored. If literature and the visual arts have given up on this project, if psychoanalysis has not yet produced convincing understanding of the mind, we can still look at the empirical study of the unconscious that is advertising. We can read the writing on the wall in the shit that the advertising companies throw at it.

And we can’t ever forget about Ballard, and what the disconcerting power of his work implies about what we are. I would love to see this memoir followed up by some substantial critical work, taking in his entire oeuvre. Equally I’d like to see something synoptic on the whole cavalcade of experimental SF writers that centered around New Worlds and Michael Moorcock. Maybe these books already exist and I am simply unaware of them - I’d welcome any recommendations in the comments. In the meantime, the essential source for all material relating to Ballard on the web is the excellent Ballardian.

April 4, 2008

Leaving The Twentieth Century

Filed under: Books, Music — Tags: , — rottenhat @ 11:23 am

The Rest Is NoiseBack in early November last year a friend emailed me a book review. The book in question wasn’t due for UK publication until March - I ordered a copy and then more or less forgot about it until it arrived a few weeks ago. I finished reading it yesterday, and I’m half-inclined to sit down and start it again immediately. The Rest Is Noise is New Yorker critic Alex Ross’ stab at a history of twentieth century classical music. Probably my scanty knowledge of classical (very scanty, as in, I probably own more cds by the Fall or the Ex alone than I do of classical in toto) increased the book’s impact. As with Simon Reynolds’ Rip It Up & Start Again, the sheer wealth of knowledge new to me was revelatory. That same ignorance means I’m not in any position to comment on the fairness or thoroughness of Ross’ treatment, but with that caveat, I will say this is one of the best books on music I have ever read. The writing is incisive and evocative - even when his discussion of individual pieces moves into technical description, he manages to convey some measure of the impact and the sound of the music, and his evident love of the music inspires (as with any good music writer) the desire to listen to the music, and to hear what he hears in it.

Ross doesn’t confine himself to a narrow definition of history, situating musical developments in a broader artistic, social and political context. Indeed the central section of the book deals with the relationship between music and politics between the wars, in Hitler’s Germany, Stalin’s Russia and Roosevelt’s USA. I think Ross would like to be able to say that art is inevitably deformed by politicization and irreducibly crippled under totalitarian governments. There’s certainly an argument that the great works produced in this period are only evidence of impossibility of achieving a truly totalitarian state. The treatment of Shostakovich’s fraught relationship with the Soviet apparat is nuanced - the more explicit Nazi sympathies of Webern and Strauss are not glossed over. He demonstrates the political influences on the emergence of Darmstadt after the war, and notes the covert funding of avant-garde music by the CIA for propaganda purposes during the Cold War. (Frances Stonor Saunders’ Who Paid The Piper is an excellent account of this somewhat surreal propaganda campaign - abstract expressionism to combat agit-prop).

The chapters are broadly thematic, avoiding strict chronology in the aim of a clearer account of the various directions of development pointing up continuities that could easily be obscured. Composers representing those who assiduously cultivated their own gardens (Sibelius and Britten) get stand-alone chapters, while Schoenberg and Stravinsky reappear throughout the book, the former setting the form for avant-garde tendencies across the century, the latter desperately striving to master the critically-acclaimed aesthetic of the day. If the book becomes more fragmented in the later chapters, it is because there are no such canonical figures as Schoenberg holding sway over an increasingly atomised tradition. The result is a fascinatingly rich, complex book, thick with character and incident. The riot at the premiere of The Rite Of Spring, he comments, was far from unique - the concert audiences at the time often divided into conservatives more than happy to give the bird to work they thought sub-par and aesthetes who were overjoyed at the opportunity to excoriate the philistine masses in response. The book is dotted with performances that end in riots - I think he nominates Steve Reich as the last major composer to receive this particular honour. Elsewhere, we see a young Morton Feldman being admonished to write music for the man in the street - looking out the window, the man passing in the street proved to be Jackson Pollock. Ross mercifully resists the temptation to shoehorn extraneous jazz and rock into the book, and generally displays decent if obvious taste when discussion spills into these areas.

The Rest Is Noise might not be a perfect book - I’ve seen some entirely reasonable criticisms elsewhere - but the scale of its’ ambition makes perfection unachievable. That it succeeds as much as it does is remarkable, and for me the measure of that success is the months and years I am going to spend listening to the music that Ross so evidently loves. That, presumably, is all the success he’s looking for.

[The man himself maintains a blog, also called The Rest Is Noise. Among other things, there is a section devoted to audio files of excerpts from pieces mentioned in the book.]

March 21, 2008

10 Recommended Recordings

Filed under: Books, Music — Tags: , — rottenhat @ 1:54 pm

December 16, 2007

A History Of Rome

Filed under: Books, Folio Society — Tags: , — rottenhat @ 2:12 pm

Mommsen“When the tribune Gabinius after the introduction of his proposals appeared in the senate-house, the fathers of the city were almost on the point of strangling him with their own hands, without considering in their zeal how extremely disadvantageous to them this method of arguing must ultimately have proved.”

- Theodor Mommsen, A History Of Rome

I last learned the history of the Republic in school, under a genial but halitotic master called Wilson. We were the last or else the second-last class in the school to be prepared for Leaving Cert Latin. In my sixth year Latin was no longer even included on the timetable so that the class became itinerant, reduced to wandering the school in search of a vacant classroom. Perhaps this had something to do with the empty gin bottle we found buried among the chess boards in Wilson’s desk, perhaps not. Since then what little I remember has been distorted and refracted through playing the monumentally messy but peculiarly satisfying Avalon Hill boardgame, and otherwise reduced to a dim haze by passage of time. In any case the idealised, programmatic version we were given in school matched Mommsen only in outline. The model form of government we were given was traduced and corrupted almost as soon as it became tradition. Mommsen practically shakes with disgust at the venality and incompetence of the republican administration, perhaps the more so to contrast with his veneration of Julius Caesar and to a lesser extent Sulla. It’s hard to conceive of a modern historian employing his vocabulary of honour, or indeed evincing his respect for the warrior, but perhaps that only illustrates how pitifully our expectations of politicians have diminished.

NB This Folio Society edition is considerably abridged, although you’ll find no mention of this on their website. At 700 pages, it was enough to satisfy me but a serious student might want to seek out a complete edition.

Blog at WordPress.com.